NOTICE
I want to start off by saying that there is a canon lesbian relationship in My Little Pony Friendship is Magic. Background ponies, Lyra and BonBon (LyraBon). They propose to each other. They get married. It’s cute.



Contentious Lesbian Ponies
This post is about the more contested lesbian ships in My Little Pony (MLP). That being Rarijack (Rarity and Applejack) and Appledash (Applejack and Rainbow Dash). These ships aren’t just contested because they share a member, Applejack, which does spark some healthy debate within MLP fan spaces. The biggest reason they are still talked about to this day is because these ships were very ambiguously yet directly acknowledged within the franchise.


Though these characters are shipped across the entire MLP franchise. The Appledash ship is more commonly associated with the classic Friendship is Magic television show (the one where they’re horses) and the Rarijack ship is associated with the Equestria Girls movies series (the one where they’re humans).
Fun Fact!
All of the images are either a part of the classic MLP Friendship is Magic or MLP Equestria Girls franchises. So yes all canon. All happened.
Rarijack (Rarity & Applejack)

Throughout the Equestria Girls franchise there are multiple places where fans impose queer readings of interactions between Rarity and Applejack. This is very common within fandom spaces, especially ones with a large queer audience. Because of the history of Hays Codes–a set of self-censorship guidelines imposed by Hollywood that often targeted explicit depictions of queerness–queer audiences are more prepared to read coded messages within their media in order to find the representation they are looking for. By this point in the greater MLP franchise the creators weren’t strangers to the fan shipping culture. And their response to the Rarijack ship was. . . Raggamuffin. . . and Dirk Thistleweed.

Immediate reaction: 1) This was most definitely on purpose. 2) If they knew people were shipping Rarity and Applejack why create new characters that look like each other to pair together? 3) Why not just pair the girls together?
I understand that queer coding is sometimes a present and necessary part of how shows are able to include queer representation without receiving backlash from higher ups or unaccepting audiences. This hinting is sometimes the only tool available to creators when writing towards a mass (not specifically queer) audience. But that’s part of what confuses me about this approach. Everyone queer or not can see that Dirk is meant to be a stand-in for Rarity and Raggamuffin is meant to be a stand-in for Applejack, so it’s not properly “coded”. At the same time this queer ship is heavily popular within the queer parts of this fandom, so when catering to the people who enjoy this ship why would they opt for this kind of “coding” rather than explicitly depicting it. It feels very deliberate, like offering audiences a heteronormative alternative that simultaneously rejects queer readings of text, but acknowledges that there are queer readings of this relationship. It’s like that thing that hegemony does where it incorporates the subversion of itself within itself in order to gain more credibility and re-assert itself as correct and normal (Berlant & Warner, “Sex in Public”).
Appledash



Appledash in the classic MLP television series is a little less problematic, but they have a lot less on-screen chemistry than Rarity and Applejack in Equestria Girls. In the series finale, The Last Problem (Season 9, Episode 26), when all of the mane six meet back up again, Applejack and Rainbow Dash enter princess Twilight’s throne room together, talking about doing chores like an old married couple. This for a lot of people was confirmation of the Appledash ship in classic MLP, but in all honesty outside of Fall Weather Friends (Season 1, Episode 13) Applejack and Rainbow Dash don’t really have a lot of episodes or even moments together. This depiction is closer to a more traditionally coded queer relationship, being ambiguous about the relationship, yet keeping the characters close. Even then the Appledash ship failed at communicating that sense of closeness throughout the previous 9 seasons, so this implied relationship, though welcomed, doesn’t feel earned.
Final Question
Is any of this representation? Especially if fans were gonna ship the ponies/girls anyway. What purpose does it serve to not fully engage with the audience? The creators are aware of the ships and seem to want to acknowledge them to give something to the fans, but these gestures feel empty and hollow (Warner, “In the Time of Plastic Representation”). Like despite trying to engage with queer readings of the characters, they don’t want to have explicitly queer characters. I do think that coding is a useful tool in art and not all queer relationships must be explicitly stated (Clark, “More Than Sex…”). Still I question what is the purpose of this specific kind of representation, that is disingenuous and heteronormative in essence? Would it have been better for the creators to leave the shipping content to the fans?
Bonus: Can you guess which ship is my favorite? Rarijack? Appledash? or a secret third option?








